Took a few years, but here is a NOS VIP Custom pencil, recently purchased from an eBay seller in Janesville. No arrow/halo. Note the 51 Signet 3-line pattern. The Custom Jotter was assembled from a 51 Signet pencil cap (the Signet Jotter, pencil, and Liquid Lead all use the same outer cap) and a 65 parts Jotter - you need a 61/65 ratchet mechanism because the barrel is shorter than a 51.
The pencil is an agglomeration of parts: 61 clip, 51 Special/21 mechanism with a gold plated tip, and a cap with the same pattern as the 51 Signet, but smaller in diameter than the cap activated pencil.

Edited by matt, 10 November 2021 - 09:23 PM.